Explaining Comparative Fault

Anderson Franco Law

In personal injury cases, determining fault is an important factor in determining compensation. However, in some situations, more than one party may share responsibility for an accident or injury. Understanding the concept of comparative fault is very helpful for navigating personal injury cases in California. This article will explain what comparative fault is, how it affects personal injury cases, and the importance of seeking legal representation to protect your rights.

Understanding Comparative Fault:

Comparative fault, also known as comparative negligence, allocates responsibility for an accident or injury among multiple parties. It recognizes that in some cases, both the plaintiff (injured party) and the defendant (alleged at-fault party) may have contributed to the incident to varying degrees. Comparative fault laws aim to ensure a fair distribution of liability and proportionate compensation. What that means is explained in the example below.

California’s Comparative Fault Law:

California follows a “pure comparative negligence” system under its comparative fault law (California Civil Code Section 1714). Under this system, an injured party can still recover damages even if they are partially at fault. The amount of compensation they receive will be reduced by their percentage of fault.

Example of Comparative Fault:

Consider a hypothetical scenario: John is driving above the speed limit when another driver, Sarah, suddenly changes lanes without signaling. The two vehicles collide, causing injuries to both parties. In this case, a court may determine that John is 60% responsible for the accident due to his speeding, while Sarah is 40% responsible for her improper lane change. Comparative fault reduces John’s compensation by his percentage of fault. If his total damages were determined to be $100,000, he would receive $40,000 (60% of $100,000). However, it’s essential to note that Sarah’s compensation would also be affected. If she suffered $50,000 in damages, she would receive $30,000 (60% of $50,000) after accounting for her percentage of fault.

Role of Evidence and Expert Testimony:

Determining the extent of comparative fault requires careful examination of evidence and expert testimony. Accident reconstruction specialists, medical professionals, and other experts may be called upon to provide their assessments and opinions. Their expertise helps establish the degree of fault and supports the injured party’s claim for compensation.

Proving Negligence:

To recover compensation in a personal injury case, it is crucial to establish negligence on the part of the defendant. Negligence refers to a failure to exercise reasonable care, resulting in harm to another person. In a comparative fault scenario, it is necessary to demonstrate that the defendant’s negligence played a significant role in causing the injuries, even if the plaintiff also shares some degree of fault.

The Importance of Legal Representation:

Navigating the complexities of comparative fault and personal injury law can be challenging without legal expertise. Hiring an experienced personal injury attorney is essential to protect your rights and maximize your potential compensation. An attorney investigates the circumstances of the accident, gathers evidence, consults experts, and builds a strong case on your behalf.

Contact Anderson Franco Law:

If you have been injured in an accident and believe that comparative fault may be a factor, reach out to contact Anderson Franco Law. Our dedicated team of personal injury attorneys has extensive experience in handling complex cases involving comparative fault. We will fight to protect your rights, navigate the legal process, and pursue the compensation you deserve. Schedule a free consultation today and let us be your advocates in your personal injury case. You can call us anytime at (415)727-1832 or email us at contact@andersonfranco.com

Final Thoughts:

Understanding these concepts are helpful when dealing with personal injury cases in California. By comprehending the impact of shared responsibility on compensation, gathering strong evidence, and seeking legal representation, injured parties can navigate the legal process more effectively. Remember, Anderson Franco Law is here to provide expert guidance and fight for your rights or the rights of your loved ones. Don’t hesitate to reach out and schedule a free consultation to discuss your personal injury case with our experienced team.

Client Reviews

I don’t know jack about law, let alone how to navigate my way through any of it. Anderson was beyond helpful and patient with me as we both dealt with a bs lawsuit. I can’t recommend him enough, and I wouldn’t waste my...


I had the pleasure of speaking with Anderson and he was super friendly and helpful and took the time to talk through and explain the various issues at play with my situation. His type of service is one that is most often...


Attorney Franco is kind and understanding. He is knowledgeable and patient to us explaining every detail of what we have to do. He will support you all the way. Thanks again Attorney.


Our Location

1 Embarcadero Ctr

San Francisco, CA 94111

Get in Touch

Fill out the contact form or call us at (415) 727-1832 to schedule your free consultation.

  • phone.png Free Consultation
  • Frame.png No Obligation Case Evaluation
  • No-Fee.png Millions Recovered for Our Clients

Contact Us Now For a Free Case Evaluation